It was only a matter of time, I suppose and isn’t any huge surprise. After stating emphatically to Wes some weeks ago the third Doctor could never even momentarily being my favorite, it’s no longer true at all.
Naturally, this has everything to do with the exclusive Pertwee/Sladen immersion program I’ve recently found myself in. I can’t bear to watch the last S! J! S! episode (with Tom Baker as the Doctor) and so I’m watching just about everything around it and after it (including episodes with the Doctor’s post-Sarah Jane companion, Leela). This is certainly not the first time I’ve exhibited this type of behavior when it comes to Who and Sarah Jane…I danced around School Reunion for a good two or three months before I watched it.
I’ve convinced myself I’ll weep like a little girl as the Doctor exits, TARDIS left and leaves S! J! S! behind, as I did the first…the second…um, and yes, the third time I watched Mrs. Peel leave Steed upon the return of her long-lost husband. And I probably will. In fact, there’s no probably about it. I get a feeling of dread in the pit of my stomach when I think about it, so naturally, it didn’t take much to convince myself of this very strong possibility of tears at Sarah Jane’s departure from the program.
But why the sudden change of heart where Jon Pertwee is concerned? It’s quite simple, really and again, has almost everything to do with Sarah Jane: even though Pertwee’s Doctor can be a bit curmudegeonly (shades of his two previous incarnations) he is also absolutely so sweet to her; I don’t remember Baker’s Doctor being so affectionate at all. Pertwee treats her as if he was her grandfather, father, or brother, which I find very appealing. One of my favorite scenes where the Doctor does just what I imagine a brother might do to a sister is in the last scene of The Monster of Peladon: he literally takes her by the ear and gets her into the TARDIS, wearing an expression of mock irritation on his face.
To her credit, though, S! J! S! is quite affectionate towards Pertwee’s Doctor, as well, being that grand daughter, daughter, or sister to him. Again, I don’t recall S! J! being so with the Fourth Doctor, but many of their serials were early on in my Who education and it might have totally passed me by.
Ahhh…another way to totally avoid that last Sarah Jane serial…thank God.